Muslim Spain has produced some of
the brightest intellectual luminaries of the Middle Ages. One of them was
Ibn Rushd, better known as Averroes in the west who is universally
acknowledged as the greatest philosopher of Islam and one of the greatest
of all times. Being a versatile genius, he influenced the course of thought
both in the east and in the west in more than one domain of knowledge.
According to George Sarton: `He was great because of the tremendous stir
he made in the minds of men for centuries. A history of Averroism would
include all the essential elements of a history of thought from the end
of the twelfth century to the end of the sixteenth, a period of four centuries
which would perhaps deserve as much as any other to be called the Middle
Ages, for it was the real transition between ancient and modern methods.'
Abu値 Walid
Muhammad Ibn Ahmad
Ibn Muhammad Ibn Rushd, known as Averroes
in the west was born in Cordova, the metropolis of Muslim Spain in 1126
AD. He came of an illustrious Muslim family of Cordova which held the high
office of the Grand Qazi for the last two generations, Ibn Rushd himself
occupying the same post in the third generation. His grandfather Abu値
Walid Muhammad
Ibn Rushd (1058-1126) was an eminent Maliki theologian, who was the
Imam of the Grand Mosque of Cordova. His father also occupied the high
office of the Qazi. The young Ibn Rushd received his education in his native
city which was the highest seat of learning in the west. He was taught
Tradition by Abu値 Qasim, Abu
Marwan Ibn Masarrat, Abu
Jafar Ibn Aziz and Abu Abdullah Marzi.
He learnt fiqh from H~afiz~
Abu Muh~ammad
Ibn Rizq. Abu Jafar,
a reputed scholar, taught him medicine. Ibn Rushd soon acquired great scholarship
in literature, law, philosophy and medicine. He was a contemporary of some
of the outstanding thinkers of Muslim Spain, including Ibn Zuhr, Ibn
Baja and Ibn Tufayl. Ibn
Rushd was a juris-consult of the first rank and was appointed Qazi
of Seville in 1169-70. In 1182-83, he was invited by the Almohade Caliph
Abu Yaqub (1163-84) to Morocco and replaced Ibn Tufayl as the Court Physician.
In the beginning, he was patronized and respected by the succeeding Almohade
Caliph Yaqub
al-Mansur (1184-99), but, when
the pent-up Berber fanaticism burst forth, he fell victim to religious
fanatics who were jealous of his genius. The Caliph had to banish him to
Lucena, a Jewish colony near Cordova. His entire library consisting of
invaluable books except the scientific ones was reduced to ashes in 1194-95.
In 1198, when the religious fanaticism subsided, Ibn Rushd was recalled
to Morocco by the Almohade Ruler Yaqub
al-Mansur, but he did not live
long to enjoy the favours of his patron and died on December 10th, 1198
at the age of 75.
Ibn Rushd was known for his
humility and hospitality. Being pensive by nature, he abhorred position
and wealth. He passed most of his time in study. He did not make any distinction
in his treatment towards friends and foes. He was a great lover of his
native land. Like Plato who in his "Republic" has highly praised Greece,
Ibn Rushd has claimed his native land, Spain, to be the rival of
Greece. According to Ptolemy, Greece possessed the best climate in the
world, but Ibn Rushd claims the same distinction for Cordova, the
capital of Muslim Spain.
Averroes, who was considered Avicenna
of the west, applied himself to philosophy, mathematics, medicine, astronomy,
logic and Islamic jurisprudence. His works have been given to the world
by Renan. `He was one of the profoundest commentators', says Munk `of Aristotle's
works'. According to Ibn al-Abar, his writings are spread over more
than twenty thousand pages, the most important works being on philosophy,
medicine and fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence). He was an eminent legist
of his time and worked as a Qazi for a considerable period. His "Bidayatu値
Mujtahid wa Nihayatu値 Muqtasid"
is, according to Abu Jafar
Dhahabi, the best book ever written on this subject. Renan has given
a detailed list of his writings in his "Averroes" (3rd Ed, Pgs 58-79).
The list totals 67 works of Ibn Rushd, including 28 on philosophy, 5 on
theology, 8 on law, 4 on grammar and 20 on medicine. He was an astronomer
of repute who wrote "Kitab fi
Harkati値 Falaq", a treatise dealing with the motion of the sphere.
He also summarized the "Almagest" of Ptolemy which was translated into
Hebrew by Jacob Anatoli in 1231. He is credited with the discovery of sunspots.
Muslim rulers had the reputation
of being the greatest patrons of learning in the world. Writing in his
well-known book "The Making of Humanity" Robert Briffault admits: `The
incorruptible treasures and delights of intellectual culture were accounted
by the princes of Baghdad, Shiraz and Cordova, the truest and proudest
pomps of their courts. But it was not a mere appendage of their princely
vanity that the wonderful growth of Islamic science and learning was fostered
by their patronage. They pursued culture with the personal ardour of an
over mastering craving. Never before and never since, on such a scale,
has the spectacle been witnessed of the ruling classes throughout the length
and breadth of a vast empire given over entirely to a frenzied passion
for the acquirement of knowledge. Learning became with them the chief business
of life. The Caliphs and the Amirs hurried
from their Diwans to closet themselves in their libraries and observatories ... Caravans
laden with manuscripts and Botanical specimens plied from Bukhara to Tigris,
from Egypt to Andulusia; embassies were sent to Constantinople and to India
for the purpose of obtaining books and teachers; a collection of Greek
authors or a distinguished mathematician was as eagerly demanded as the
ransom of an Empire.' The Umayyad Caliph of Spain, al-Hakam had
founded a magnificent library containing about half a million books. He
had accumulated a rare collection of books on eastern philosophy and was
instrumental in creating a taste for philosophy in Spain which in later
years produced some of the greatest Muslim philosophers in the west, including
Ibn Rushd. About two centuries later, another Muslim ruler of the
West, Abdu値 Mu知in, who was himself a great scholar had drawn to
his court a galaxy of talented thinkers, including Ibn Tufayl and
Ibn Rushd. The learned Averroes owed his knowledge in philosophy
to Abu Ja`far
Harun,
a well-known rationalist of Andulusia. But the philosophy of Ibn Baja reached its climax in Averroes who surpassed his teacher and rose to
be the greatest commentator and exponent of Aristotelian philosophy in
the world. Together with Ibn Massara and Ibn Arabi, Ibn
Rushd forms the trio of the greatest Arabian thinkers of Spain. The
first two were essentially mystic, while the third (Averroes) was a rationalist.
His chief philosophical work is "Tahafutu値
Tahafut" (The Refutation of the
Refutation), which was written in refutation of al-Ghazali's work, "Tahafutu値 Falasifa"
(The Refutation of Philosophy). This work of Averroes evoked severe
criticism and stirred bitter reaction throughout the Muslim world. A strong
refutation of Ibn Rushd痴 arguments in "Tahafutu値
Tahafut" was made by a Turk, Mustafa
Ibn Yusuf al-Bursawi,
commonly known as Khwajah Zada (d:1487) who wrote a third refutation. This indicated once more the
weakness of human understanding and the strength of faith. But, contrary
to Muslim reactions, the philosophical writings of Averroes produced a
great impact on Christian Europe and he still continues to be the most
popular Muslim philosopher in the West. Alfred Gillaume in his article
on philosophy and theology in his "Legacy of Islam" writes: `Ibn Rushd
belongs to Europe and European thought rather than to the east ...
Averroism continued to be a living factor in European thought until the
birth of modern experimental science. Latin is said to have preserved more
than one of Ibn Rushd痴 works which Arabic had lost.' His "Tahafutu値
Tahafut" is essentially a reply
to al-Ghazali's attack on rationalism.
His fame as a philosopher, specially in the west, both in Christian and
Jewish circles is based on his three commentaries of Aristotle's works
known as the "Jami`" (Summary),
the "Talkhis"
(Resume) and a long "Tafsir or Sharah"
(Commentary). These commentaries were translated into Hebrew by Samuel
Ibn Tibbun in the first half of the thirteenth century, by Jacob
Anatoli in 1232 and by Michael Scott and Hermann into Latin. These translations
were later revised in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. Among his
other philosophical treatises are "Kitab
Fasl u値 Maqal"
and the "Kitab Kashfu値 Manahij",
which were edited by M.J. Muller and published in Munich in 1859.
Regarding predestination, Ibn Rushd
maintained that man was `neither the absolute master of his destiny
nor bound by fixed immutable decrees, but, that the truth lay in the middle'
`Human actions depend partly on free-will and partly on outside causes.
These causes spring from general laws of nature, God alone knows their
sequence.' According to him, man should make utmost efforts to attain perfection
which implies complete identification with the active universal intellect.
This human perfection can only be attained through study, speculation and
negation of desires specially those relating to the senses.
Ibn Rushd considered the Pious
Caliphate as the model republic in which the dreams of Plato were realized.
He claimed women to be equal to men in all respects and possessing equal
capacities to shine in war and peace. He has cited women warriors among
Greeks, Arabs and Africans.
Ibn Rushd was the most learned
commentator of Aristotelian works and was more Aristotelian than Ibn
Sina. He
corrected some of the misconceptions of Ibn Sina about the rational philosophy
of Aristotle. A number of his invaluable works perished when the Christian
conquerors set fire to the intellectual treasures of the Moors (Spanish
Muslims) amassed after centuries of intellectual activity. More than eighty
thousand rare manuscripts were reduced to ashes in Grenada alone. Muslim
thinkers like Ibn Sina and Ibn Rushd formulated their ideas with logical precision
and in the latter Arabic philosophy reached its apogee. It is all the more
creditable for the learned Averroes that he compiled his varied and invaluable
works in such a distracted state of mind and disturbed conditions.
In the beginning, philosophy was considered
to be an irreligious subject in Muslim Spain where the society was formulated
on true Islamic lines. Ishaq
Ibn `Umran, a physician of Baghdad
was first to introduce philosophy in Spain, which flourished thereafter,
specially during the reigns of al-Hakam and Yusuf
Ibn Mu知in. The ideas of Ibn Rushd were incompatible with the
religious sentiments of the orthodox Muslims and he was accused of being
an atheist. But, according to Phillip K. Hitti: `He was a rationalist and
claimed the right to submit everything save the revealed dogmas of faith
to the judgement of reason, but he was not a free thinker or disbeliever.'
George Sarton also holds similar views: `Ibn Rushd was not by any
means less honest and sincere, nor was he necessarily less pious, than
the other schoolmen, but he was more intelligent, and his deeper vision
enabled him to reconcile statements which seemed irreconcilable to others.'
Ibn Rushd, being a rationalist wanted to explain religion in the
light of reason. His contemporary Abdu値 Kabir,
a highly religious person, describes him as a person anxious to establish
harmony between religion and philosophy. In his well-known book "Averroes
and Averroism", Renan writes: `There is nothing to prevent our supposing
that Ibn Rushd was a sincere believer in Islamism, especially when
we consider how little irrational the supernatural element in the essential
dogmas of this religion is, and how closely this religion approaches the
purest Deism.'
Ibn Rushd, a versatile genius,
is the author of about twenty medical treatises including his encyclopaedic
work "Kitabu値 Kulliyat
fi al-Tibb" (General Rules of Medicine),
better known as "Colliget" in Latin. This book written before 1162 comprises
seven volumes, and gives elaborate treatment to physiology, general pathology,
diagnosis, materia medica, hygiene and general theraeutics. He considered
that none suffers twice from smallpox. He also fully understood the function
of the retina. But his "Colliget" stands no comparison to "Continents"
of Rhazes and "Canon" of Avicenna. Actually his fame as a physician was
eclipsed by his fame as a philosopher. His "Kulliyat"
was first translated into Latin by the Jew Bonacosa in the latter half
of the thirteenth century. It was again translated into Latin by Syphorien
Champier in about 1537. It was twice translated into Hebrew. `In Spain,
the philosophical bias predominated among medical men', remarks Max Meyerhof.
`The prototypes of this combination are the two Muslims, Ibn Zuhr (Avenzoar)
and Ibn Rushd (Averroes).'
Muslim Spain has produced some talented
musicians both theorists and practical musicians. Ibn Baja (d:1138) known
as Avempace, who as a musical theorist, occupies the same place in the
west which Farabi occupies in the east. Ibn Rushd has also made invaluable contribution
to musical theory by writing a commentary on Aristotle's "De Anima" dealing
perspicuously with the theory of sound. This was translated into Latin
by Michael Scot (d: 1232).
A number of his biographies have appeared
in different languages but the most elaborate account of his life and works
is found in "Averroes et j' averrosime" written by Ernest Renan published
in Paris in 1852. `This admirable work', says George Sarton, `has justly
become a classic; it is a penetrating study which every student of mediaeval
philosophy ought to read, but it must be used with caution.'
It has been customary with the western
writers to minimize the intellectual attainments of Muslim thinkers, but
now the less partial researches have lifted this veil and their achievements
stand in all their glory. Alfred Guillaume says: `We may be sure that those
who accuse the Muslim scholars of lack of originality and of intellectual
decadence have never read Averroes or looked into Algazel but have adopted
second hand judgements. The presence of doctrines of Islamic origin in
the very citadel of Western Christianity, the `Summa' of Aquinas, is a
sufficient refutation of the charge of lack of originality and sterility.'
The works of Ibn Rushd which
were very popular in the west were translated into several European languages
including Latin, Hebrew, German and English. It was through his commentaries
that the west learned about Aristotle and other Greek thinkers. The Latin
"Editio Princeps" of Aristotle with Averroes' commentaries was published
about fifty times in Venice alone. Andrea Alpago of Belluno in Italy (d:1520)
translated into Latin, Avicenna's "Canon" and the minor works of Averroes.
The Italian emperor Frederik, the Great, who, on account of being a great
patron of Muslim culture, was accused by the Bishops to have embraced Islam,
was instrumental in getting translated a number of Arabic books, including
those of Averroes.
Thus, the works of Averroes which
were not so popular in Islamic countries wielded considerable influence
in the western thought, both Christian and Jewish.`He deeply influenced
Jewish philosophy through many translations and disciples', writes George
Sarton, in his monumental work "An Introduction to the Study of Science".
`Jewish Averroism reached its zenith under Levi ben Gershon in the first
half of the fourteenth century, and it continued to prosper until the end
of the fifteenth century. The Christian schoolmen were influenced by the
Jewish, and in various ways.' According to Phillip K. Hitti: `The last
of the great Arabic writing philosophers, Ibn Rushd belonged more to Christian
Europe than to Muslim Asia or Africa. To the west, he became the commentator
as Aristotle was `The Teacher'. From the end of the twelfth to the end
of the sixteenth century, Averroism remained the dominant school of thought,
and that, in spite of the orthodox reaction, it created first among the
Muslims in Spain, then among the Talmudists and finally among the Christian
clergy ... After being purged of objectionable matter by ecclesiastical
authorities, his writings became prescribed studies in the University of
Paris and other institutions of higher learning. With all its excellence
and other misconceptions collected under its name, the intellectual movement
initiated by Ibn Rushd continued to be a living factor in European thought
until the birth of modern experimental science'.
(Extracted from "The Hundred Great Muslims")
|