Question: Why
can’t women give the Friday sermon or lead the Friday prayer?
Answer: Before
I answer this question, I would like to point out that in this regard,
the Sunnah set by the Prophet (sws) is that the head of state and
his representatives should deliver address and lead the Friday prayers
in the various mosques of an Islamic state. However, in case of any legitimate
plea on their part, some other person can address and lead the Friday prayers
as their authorized representative.
The implications of this Sunnah
are very clear: In Islam, mosques are meant to be the fountainhead
of authority. Also, there is a complete negation of theocracy. A person
whom the Muslims choose as their leader shall also lead them in worship,
eliminating once and for all the division between state and religion.
After the Prophet (sws), his Companions
solemnly adhered to this Sunnah in the Caliphate they established.
However, in later times when, owing to their own ill-ways, the Muslim rulers
could not stand face to face with the public, they themselves handed over
the mosques to the ulema. This was perhaps one of the most tragic
incident in our history. The result was that religion lost its grace and
the state its grandeur.
Today religious scholars are forced
to assume charge of the mosques because of this sorry state of affairs.
In this situation, coming to your
question, I think no religious objection can be raised on a lady giving
the Friday Sermon. This is more like delivering a lecture. If a learned
lady wants to deliver a talk on some Islamic topic in the Friday Sermon,
she should be allowed to. There may be cultural hindrances to this -- but
then, if they can be overcome, I personally think that there is nothing
wrong with it.
Leading the prayer congregation consisting
of men whether it be of Friday or of the other five prayers however, in
accordance with the established Sunnah of the Prophet (sws), is the responsibility
of men. Keeping in view the norms of modesty men, it seems, are more suited
for this task. Of course, if a woman leads a congregation of women only,
then this cannot be objected to.
|