Question: In the Qur’an,
God seems to show displeasure at being assigned daughters as opposed to
sons. Is this indicating a preference for one gender over the other? There
are so many horrendous things happening to Muslim women around the world,
it seems like we need to do more for them, but this preference for boys
over girls seems to be dominating our minds (as well as other countries).
Are not women equal to men?
Answer: You are probably referring
to Qur’an 53:21 in your question concerning the apparent displeasure
that God seems to display over being assigned daughters. First, if one
views the style of Arabic language in this particular verse, it is clear
that the Qur’an is employing ‘irony’ as a means of conveying its
point. There is no intention of showing displeasure or signifying a preference
in God’s eyes towards one gender. It may be best to read the following
verse with the words ‘It is ironic that …’ in brackets before the verse.
In addition to the linguistic suggestion that this is not a ‘preference’
for sons, it must be clear that the Qur’an has stressed over and
again that God has no offspring, sons or daughters. Hence, it would not
make sense for God to prefer sons over daughters because contextually a
reading of the entire Qur’an shows that God finds incredible displeasure
in either of them being assigned to Him. For instance:
Those who say: The Compassionate [God] has begotten
a son, certainly preach such a monstrous falsehood that the very Heavens
might crack, the earth might cleave asunder and the mountains might crumble
to pieces – at their ascribing a son to the Compassionate [God], It is
not befitting to the Compassionate [God] that He should beget a son. (19:88-92)
With regard to the preference of boys
over girls as a global phenomenon, unfortunately this is very true in many
societies, not only Muslim ones, but particularly Third World countries.
There was an evil practice of infanticide (burying alive girls at birth)
rampant among the pre-Islamic Arabs which the Qur’an banned completely.
As you have described, sometimes this preference is a result of society
and the lack of value it has given to girls or the ‘costs’ associated with
girls (for instance, in South Asia, the traditions associated with marriage
have placed an incredible burden upon parents seeking to marry their daughters,
many times leaving them in life-threatening debt for the remainder of their
lives). Hence, although in some respects one can understand the potential
burdens that parents may feel with daughters – this is a problem caused
by the society and not by the girls. Hence, we must not punish them for
it devalues their existence. We must change the traditions in our
societies in order to properly end this attitude.
I encourage you to champion the cause
of the status of women all over the world, in Muslim societies and the
West. Unfortunately, despite the advancements that the West has made
with regard to technology, there are still terrible circumstances that
many women live in. Domestic abuse in the United States is rampant
and widespread according to many studies conducted by various women’s centers
and there are countless instances of rape occurring every day. These are
serious ailments that are present in the West, just like domestic abuse,
honor killings, and general disregard for women’s rights degrade our own
Muslim societies. Sincere efforts to address these issues are needed.
With regard to equality, I think this
word is often abused because many times it implies that there are no differences
between people. Reality indicates that there are differences between people
and genders on the basis of different factors. In some circumstances, one
group may be a level above another group, and then vice versa for an alternative
situation. For instance, although a husband is given some authority over
the family, the Prophet (sws) has indicated that heaven lies at a mother’s
feet.
|